
The three Vedantic Darsanas - Dvaita, Advaita and Vishishtadvaita
Commentary by Sarangarajan Serangolam Rajagopalan (aka) Nikesh Anand
Darshanas distinct from Philosophies deal with the following topics metaphysics, Knowledge, source of knowledge, ethics & aesthetics.
It is in Metaphysics the Vedantic darsanas vary. Vedantic Darsanas need to answer these six questions
1) Nature of the Soul
2) Nature of God (Brahman)
3) Nature of Universe (Jagat)
4) Means to attain Brahman (Sadhana)
5) Result of the Sadhana (Purusharta) – what happens after successfully doing the sadhana
6) Impediments to sadhana and the purusharta
Advaita
The Framework
1) Nature of the soul – Soul is Vibhu (pervades everything) and is same as Brahman . Soul is also independent
2) Nature of Brahman – Brahman is nivesesha chinmatra – Attribute less formless pure existence
3) Nature if Universe – Universe in an illusion
4) Means to attain Brahman – is through Gyana yoga – power of knowledge developed through repeatedly listening to maha vakyas in upanishads, contemplating and meditating upon those meanings
5) Results of Sadhana – Crosses the bondage of thinking I am this I am that and realizes I am the brahman itself
6) Impediments to Sadhana – Maya / the veil that makes one think of oneself as anything other than brahman
Description
While proposing his ideas about Jiva Brahma unity and the nature of Universe being an illusion Shankara strongly condemned the views of duality, Sankkhya (the view that considers Matter and not Brahman as the source of everything) and Bhuddas. Contrary to the popular belief Shankara devotes most of his time to oppose the Sankhya theory and not Bhouddas in his works.
It is brahman that shows up as many Jivas. just like how the sun can be seen as different suns in different mirrors the same brahman shows up as different jivas when conditioned by bodies (upadis). It is the Maya (the illusionary force) that keeps the Jiva stuck in the body and when it fully realizes it is brahmam then it attains liberation.
Shankara completely rejects the ritualistic portion of the vedas and prescribes 4 pre conditions for one to start the journey of realizing brahman – 1) Discernment towards permanence and impermanence 2) having dispassion towards worldly and heavenly enjoyments 3) ethical conduct, internal purity and penance 4) intent desire towards liberation
Shankara besides the 10 Upanishad bhashyams, brahma sutra bashyam and gita bashyam has also written an independent work called Viveka Chudamani. Many of his other works like Baja Govindam, Shiva Nanda Lahari, Soundarya Lahari etc are considered to be wrongly attributed to him.
Vishishtadvaita
The Framework
1) Nature of the soul – Soul is Anu (atomic but pervades the body it has taken) and is part of Brahman . Soul is dependent on brahman, Souls are innumerable and are eternal. Souls also have attributes.
2) Nature of Brahman – Brahman is sa visesha (full of blemishless attributes) and pervades everything else. Brahman can be formless and with form. Brahman is the sum total of everything. It is the soul of the souls (aatma of Jivatmas).
3) Nature of Universe – Universe in real (Pravahataha nityam ) – Like how the river is permanent even though the water at any particular place keeps changing, universe is also permanent but keeps changing every moment.
4) Means to attain Brahman – is through bhakti yoga – Bhakti is defined as unceasing meditation on the Brahman. Though Ramanuja recommended Bhakti Yoga as the path to liberation in Sri Bhashyam and Gita Bhashyam, in his independent works (Gadya Trayam), he only recommends Sharanagati / self-surrender as the path to salvation
5) Results of Sadhana – Reaches the abode of Brahman and continues in direct bhakti
6) Impediments to Sadhana – Thinking that I am independent (Svatantra) is the source of all bondages
Description
There is sufficient proof to show that Vishistadvaitha existed for at least 1000 years before the time of Ramanuja as it can be found from the references Ramanuja makes on yester year acharyas who wrote Vyakyanams to Brahma Sutra – Tanka, Dramida and Bodhayana to name a few. It is Bodhayana’s work that Ramanuja used to reestablish Vishitadvaita. Ramanuja in his works calls his darsana as Savisesha Advaita – it is much later after Ramanuja’s time it came to be known as Visistadvaitha.
It was Alavandar (Yamanucharya -Ramanuja’s perceptors Perceptor) who indirectly inspired Ramanuja in to writing Sri Bhashyam a large work on Brahma Sutram. Before completing Sri Bhashyam, Ramanuja had written two shorter versions of Bhashyams for Brahma sutram –Vedanta Deepam and Vedanta Saram.
In Sri Bhashya Ramanuja dedicates most of his time in objecting Advaita and Sankhya. Ramanuja tries to create a synthesis between seemingly conflicting orientations present in the vedas and upanishads. While Shankara completely rejects the Purva Mimamsa (ritualistic), Ramanuja accepts it and makes it as a stepping stone for one to reach the vendantic fold.
While Shankara relies on the advaitic (non-dualistic – abheda) passages in upanishads and Madhva relies on dualistic (bhedha) statements of upanishads, ramanuja focusses on integrating all of them through passages that talk integrate both dualism and non-dualism (these are called ghataka sruthis). Antaryaami brahmanam in Brihadaranyaka upanishad forms the basis for his arguments. According to Ramanuja the entire universe is body of Brahman and the matter and souls (jiva) are his limbs (angas). This is called as shareera shareeri bhava. He thus integrates the dualistic and non-dualistic aspects of vedic passages in to a non-dualistic brahman yet with attributes.
Ramanuja travelled the country two times and popularized bhakti – Several Vaishnava traditions and bhakti cult sprung up all over India due to his works and the works of teachers who came in his lineage. Besides Bhakti Ramanuja lays lot of stress on Service to God and humanity and he set up a lineage of 74 acharyas to carry over service and to spread vaishnavism. During his time, Ramanuja had a wide following of 700 sanyasis and 11,000 well learned acharyas and several thousands of commoners. Ramanuja is also known for his social reforms.
Ramanuja has written 9 works – 3 Gadyams [Sharanagadi, Sri Ranga and Vaikunta], Gita Bhashyam, Sri Bhashyam, Vedartha Sangraha, Vedanta Deepa, Vedanta Sara and Nitya Grantha.
Dvaita
The Framework
1) Nature of the soul – Soul is anu (atomic) and is totally distinct and outside of Brahman . Soul is dependent on Brahman
2) Nature of Brahman – Brahman is distinct from Matter and Souls. He is the source of matter and souls
3) Nature if Universe – Universe is real
4) Means to attain Brahman – is through bhakti yoga alone
5) Results of Sadhana – Reaches the abode of Vishnu
6) Impediments to Sadhana – Soul thinking it is independent
Description
This is the most popular philosophy knowingly are unknowingly followed by all. Even advaitis and vishistadvaithis before self-realization
consider themselves in the dualistic mode.
In dvaita a Jiva remains always distinct and a slave to brahman. it relinquishes the bondage through bhakti yoga and reaches the abode of brahman and enjoys the bliss of being in the presence of brahman.
Like Ramanuja Madhva too wrote shorter bhashyams for brahma sutram. He has written 4 bhashyams for brahma sutram itself. Besides the Gita Bhashyam and Upanishad bhashyams, Madhavacharya has also written several independent works including his magnum opus (mahabharata tatparya nirnaya).
In his works Madhvacharya singles out advaitam and vehemently refutes it.
IndiYatra – We bring you quizzes on India’s heritage, history and festivals.
Learn about the archaeology and antiquity of our festivals.
Discover the geographical diversity and cultural variety of our celebrations.
Relate our living heritage with the lived history.
Look out for the quizzes at each festival or celebration day.
Start the next festival day with a new quiz. Join our “Notification Only” Groups.
Thank you very much!
Thanks a lot
Pranams. Thank you very much for divine information
Namaste and you are most welcome. Please consider joining the Quiz Notification groups.
Namaste, request you to create the quizzes in local Indian languages as well to reach to the larger audience. Great work
Millions of thanks